Memorandum
- From
- Delaney Sawyer via fox - Opinion
- Date
- Filed
- Politics·4 min to read
- Re
Washington voters' women's sports law faces ACLU lawsuit
ReWashington voters' women's sports law faces ACLU lawsuit
The American Civil Liberties Union has sued to block Washington state's Initiative 638, approved by voters to protect women's sports, and a former high school runner says the measure is needed to preserve fair competition.
The American Civil Liberties Union is seeking to overturn Initiative 638, a Washington state ballot measure that voters approved to protect women's sports, prompting a legal fight over whether the law will stand. The ACLU has asked a state court to block the measure, and the state attorney general's office has indicated it will defend the initiative in court.
The measure passed in early November by a margin of more than 10 percentage points, with support from both Democrats and Republicans. Voters in four states, including Arizona, Colorado, Nebraska and Washington, approved similar measures on the November 3 ballot, joining 27 states that have passed legislation on the issue. Supporters argue that the initiative was necessary because the state's legislators did not act on the matter themselves.
The opinion piece supporting the measure was written by a former high school track athlete who says she was named her school's Female Track and Field Athlete of the Year three years in a row. She argues that competing against athletes who went through male puberty puts female athletes at a disadvantage that training cannot overcome. She recalled that her girls' 4x400-meter relay team lost to a male athlete who had previously competed in the high school boys' category, and that the same athlete went on to win the state championship in the women's 400-meter race two years in a row.
Alliance Defending Freedom is representing Female Athletes United, a coalition of female athletes, in a motion to intervene in the ACLU's lawsuit. The author said she is filing a declaration as part of the case. Last year she filed a complaint with the U.S. Department of Education's Office for Civil Rights, asking it to investigate the state's athletic policies and require that sex-designated sports categories be based on sex.
The author also cited other cases to support her position. She pointed to Kallie Keeler, a female wrestler who she said was harmed during a high school women's wrestling match against a competitor who turned out to be male, and said coaches and officials had not told her in advance. She also cited a United Nations report that documents more than 600 female athletes across 29 sports who have been displaced by men, with the men collectively taking more than 890 medals. In West Virginia, she said, one male athlete defeated more than 470 girls over 1,400 times in a single sport.
That West Virginia case led to State of West Virginia v. B.P.J., which the U.S. Supreme Court decided last summer in a ruling that states can protect women's sports. The opinion piece frames the Washington initiative as a defense of Title IX, the federal law passed decades ago to ensure equal opportunity for women in education and athletics, which the author says is being undermined by social and political movements.
The ACLU's challenge sets up a court test of whether the ballot measure can stand. The outcome will determine whether Washington's voter-approved policy remains in effect while the case proceeds.
27
Source: Washington voters protected women’s sports. ACLU wants to overturn democracy
