Memorandum
- From
- Delaney Sawyer via fox - Politics
- Date
- Filed
- Politics·5 min to read
- Re
Trump calls Cornyn's blocking of Texas judicial pick a tremendous disservice
ReTrump calls Cornyn's blocking of Texas judicial pick a tremendous disservice
President Donald Trump criticized Senator John Cornyn for refusing to return a blue slip for Trump's nominee to a Dallas federal judgeship, a move that effectively stalls the nomination. Cornyn has defended his position, and Senator Ted Cruz has publicly backed the nominee while describing a heated exchange with Cornyn.
President Donald Trump has accused outgoing Texas Senator John Cornyn of doing a "tremendous disservice" by refusing to advance his nominee to a federal judicial seat in Dallas. Speaking to Fox News' "Saturday in America," Trump said that the delay would allow what he called a "radical left lunatic" to take the seat, and he made clear he does not want that outcome.
At the center of the dispute is the "blue slip" tradition, which gives home-state senators a voice in judicial nominations. Returning a blue slip signals approval for a nominee to move forward, while withholding it effectively blocks the process. Cornyn told The Associated Press that he has no intention of returning the slip for T. Elliot Gaiser, a senior Department of Justice lawyer whom Trump nominated to the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas.
Trump argued that the nominee is being held up for personal reasons. "Everybody tells me he's outstanding and he's being held up by John Cornyn because John Cornyn's feelings were hurt," he said. Trump, who endorsed Cornyn's challenger Ken Paxton in the Texas Republican Senate primary, also said Cornyn had lost that race badly. "He was beaten in the primary. And he's - he feels badly about it," Trump said, adding, "He's a nice guy, John Cornyn, but he's doing a tremendous disservice because Gaiser is fantastic."
Cornyn responded on X later on Saturday. He questioned why Trump waited until after the midterm elections to nominate someone for a Dallas vacancy that, he noted, has existed since 2025. He said the nominee, Gaiser, is a non-Texan with little connection to the state, has no trial court experience and has not been appropriately vetted for a lifetime appointment. Cornyn argued that the Senate's constitutional role of "advice and consent" is impossible to fulfill without consultation.
Cornyn also said he would still like to work with the president to fill the seat while Republicans hold a Senate majority. He said he had forwarded a candidate who was highly rated by a bipartisan Federal Judicial Evaluation Committee, co-chaired with Senator Cruz, and who has already been interviewed by White House Counsel. According to Cornyn, that candidate needs only an FBI background check, which the bureau is prepared to conduct promptly. "Back to you, Mr. President. Time is of the essence," he wrote.
Senator Ted Cruz, a Texas Republican, called Cornyn's decision "really frustrating" and described a tense encounter the two had this week on the Senate floor. Cruz said he asked Cornyn to let the nomination proceed and offered to make the case on the merits. He said Cornyn declined even to meet with the nominee. Cruz claimed the exchange grew heated, with Cornyn becoming angry, and he said he had told Cornyn that blocking the nomination would hand the seat to Democrats.
Cruz said the nominee was chosen because the timeline for a brand-new candidate was too tight. He explained that the FBI background check for a new nominee takes weeks, and there was not enough time before year's end to complete that process. Instead, the White House proposed Gaiser, who currently heads the Office of Legal Counsel at the Justice Department. Cruz noted that Gaiser clerked for Justice Sam Alito at the U.S. Supreme Court and served as a state solicitor general arguing cases before that court. Cruz said he interviewed Gaiser and described him as "incredibly principled, smart, capable, ready."
Cruz also explained the mechanics of the situation. Any single senator from a state can block a district court nomination by withholding the blue slip, and Cruz said that is what Cornyn did. The result, he said, is that the Dallas seat will remain vacant and the people of Dallas will not have a judge in it. Cruz also pointed to a broader concern among Republicans, saying they want to confirm as many judges as possible before the end of the year because they expect Democrats to block judicial confirmations when they take over in January.
Cruz said a separate Texas vacancy in Austin is moving forward and that the judge there is expected to be confirmed by the end of the year. The Dallas seat, however, remains stalled, and it is unclear whether the two sides can reach an agreement before the Senate's majority changes hands.
20
Source: Trump says Sen Cornyn is doing a 'tremendous disservice' by blocking Texas judicial pick
