Core Memo

Memorandum

To
Anyone who needs the day in one page
Date
November 21, 2026

Memorandum

From
Caroline Mercer via IGN Articles
Date
Filed
Culture·3 min to read
Re

Nicalis removes undisclosed AI-generated music from Binding of Isaac update

ReNicalis removes undisclosed AI-generated music from Binding of Isaac update

Developer Nicalis removed AI-generated music from The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ after players flagged it, sparking a review-bombing campaign on Steam and a response from creator Edmund McMillen.

© ign.com

Developer Nicalis has removed AI-generated music from The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ after the material drew backlash, a wave of negative reviews on Steam and a public response from the game's creator, Edmund McMillen. The tracks were included in an update released November 19, 2026, and were not disclosed in the game's description or any official communication before launch.

The controversy began the day after release, when a Reddit user identified as ShweetsStuff reported that music tied to a Grand Theft Auto-themed daily run appeared to be generated by Suno, an AI music software. The user pointed to several tracks whose metadata referenced Suno and included links to their Suno pages. The music was linked to a run meant to coincide with the recent release of GTA 6, a joke that quickly turned into a dispute over undisclosed AI use. Valve requires developers to disclose how they have used AI during game development, which intensified criticism that the update had been released without any change to the Steam description.

Players responded with a review-bombing campaign. Only about 8 percent of the game's recent Steam reviews are positive, and many comments referenced the AI material directly. One widely shared review criticized the addition of what it called AI slop to an existing game, while another argued that the inclusion of AI should entitle buyers who had already purchased and played the game to refunds. Recent Steam reviews for Repentance+ now sit in the Overwhelmingly Negative category.

McMillen addressed the backlash on social media, saying he woke up to a mess and had no idea the daily run included generated music. He said he was looking into how it had happened and would have it removed. Hours later, Nicalis released a patch confirming the removal of generated music files. The update is live on PC, and the studio said it has been submitted to Microsoft, Nintendo and Sony for the other platforms, though no release timing was given for those versions. The studio did not explain how or why the AI-generated music entered the build, saying only that it was working on the game and would continue to address new and old bugs. McMillen also asked players to report issues and bugs to the developers.

The episode comes as the update also brought Repentance+ to new platforms, including the Nintendo Switch 2, PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X/S. It highlights a broader tension in games and other creative fields, where audiences increasingly expect clear disclosure when machines help produce art, and where undisclosed use can quickly damage trust in a studio, even after the content is removed.

6Views

Caroline Mercer

Author

World News Correspondent

Caroline Mercer covers public affairs, politics, business, culture and daily news for Core Memo. The role focuses on verification, context, and clear explanations for readers.

Source: The Binding of Isaac Dev Removes Undisclosed AI-Generated Music From Repentance+ Following Creator Response, Review-Bombing

Encl.More under Culture