Memorandum
- From
- Caroline Mercer via fox - Most Popular
- Date
- Filed
- Politics·4 min to read
- Re
Judge lets Trump's $15 billion defamation suit against New York Times proceed
ReJudge lets Trump's $15 billion defamation suit against New York Times proceed
A federal judge has allowed the core of President Donald Trump's $15 billion defamation lawsuit against The New York Times to move forward, dismissing most other challenged statements.
A federal judge has allowed the core of President Donald Trump's $15 billion defamation lawsuit against The New York Times to move forward, a ruling Trump's legal team hailed as a victory. U.S. District Judge Steven D. Merryday denied the newspaper's motion to dismiss four counts centered on seven specific accusations of criminal conduct against the president.
Trump's lawyers argued that The New York Times and publisher Penguin Random House acted with reckless disregard for the truth, pointing to what they described as "purposeful avoidance of the truth" in a book written by Times journalists. The book at the center of the dispute is "Lucky Loser: How Donald Trump Squandered His Father's Fortune and Created the Illusion of Success," written by Susanne Craig and Russ Buettner. The lawsuit names the Times, Penguin Random House and the authors.
In his written decision, Merryday sharply criticized the authors for presenting definitive claims of complex tax fraud and money laundering without a formal legal opinion or forensic auditing. He noted that the accusations were made against Trump and his father without any charges or convictions. Merryday wrote that the facts alleged in the complaint create at least a plausible inference that the authors and publishers knew no reliable conclusion about violations of tax laws, particularly estate and gift tax laws, could be reached without qualified legal analysis, which they failed to obtain.
The judge also rejected the newspaper's reliance on outside commentators. Quotes from a former prosecutor who said a Trump transaction "smells like a crime" and from a professor who called the action "suspicious" were not enough, in Merryday's view, to remove serious doubt about the accuracy of statements accusing a specific person of fraud or tax evasion. He wrote that a superficial characterization by an expert is far from a formal legal opinion.
The ruling was not a complete win for the president. Merryday dismissed two counts and threw out 27 other challenged statements as non-actionable under the strict First Amendment protections established in New York Times Co. v. Sullivan. He also denied Trump's request to amend his complaint a third time. The judge ordered The New York Times to file a formal answer within 28 days.
A New York Times spokesperson said the paper was encouraged by the dismissal of almost all claims against it. The spokesperson said the Times continues to believe the remaining claim has no legal merit and framed the case as a defense of the rights of a free and independent press. Trump's legal spokesman, responding to Fox News Digital, said the ruling showed the defendants would now have to answer for what the president's team described as intentional and malicious defamation.
The case is one of several legal fights Trump has pursued against major news organizations. The ruling leaves the lawsuit alive on a narrow set of claims while the court moves toward the next stage of pleadings.
27
Source: Trump clears hurdle in $15 billion lawsuit against New York Times
